Welcome!

To all those reading this I am David Gibbs; I am a Lecturer in Law at the University of East Anglia.

I created this blog as a general out-let of ideas for my research, as well as keeping those interested up-to-date on my research and general interests.

I completed my PhD thesis at the University of East Anglia in 2014. The thesis was recommended for the award of PhD with no corrections. My external examiner was Prof. Simon Deakin (Cambridge) and internal examiner was Prof. Morten Hviid.
My PhD research centred on directors' duties and company law. The thesis was titled 'Non-Executive Self-Interest: Fiduciary Duties and Corporate Governance'. It was a doctrinal and empirical study on whether self-interest was suitably controlled amongst non-executive directors.

My supervisors were Prof. Mathias Siems, Prof. Duncan Sheehan, Dr. Sara Connolly and Dr. Rob Heywood

All opinions of any existing or future blogpost are my own. They do not necessarily represent the views of any of my associated institutions.
ORCID 0000-0002-6596-8536



Showing posts with label shareholder vote. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shareholder vote. Show all posts

Monday, 28 November 2016

Theresa May on Corporate Governance: A misguided approach?

When last I wrote, I rose some preliminary objections to the idea of employee representation on corporate boards in the UK. I am not against strengthening the position of employees because I do not believe the current 'normative consensus' espoused by Hansmann and Kraakman: that the best way to achieve aggregate social welfare is through running the company in the collective interests of shareholders.

However, I noted that giving employees a voice on the board would be nothing more than a palatable political response because of the legal structure in companies it probably would not change the way companies operate. An employee representative would be under the same duties as any other director and it may cause new conflicts of interest or raise questions as to their independent judgement.

Now, fortunately, her government appears to have rowed back from this position and it is being reported instead that the proposed reforms will include:

1. Introduce corporate governance codes to private companies
2. Require companies to publish pay ratio between CEO chief executive and average employee
3. Improve effectiveness of remuneration committees and the extent to which they should consult shareholders and the wider company
4. Introduce binding votes on executive pay packages

The reasons behind this reform are, supposedly, to 'increase public trust in business in the face of the rise in anti-globalisation and anti-business sentiment'.

In response to this, the common objection is dusted off that more controls on business and boards will lead to some sort of mass exodus of top management talent from the country, just as there was a mass exodus from Britain after Brexit and America after Trump... as if the only thing tying management to this country is whether or not shareholders have a binding say on their pay.

Yet, what I object to under these proposals is the government's inability to think outside the box. Everytime, there is a scandal we hear the same story: "More shareholder power", that is the answer, despite seemingly ignoring considerable evidence that shows increasing shareholder power does not improve business.

There is the work from Cheffins that shows increase in investor confidence often comes from essentially soft forms of control rather than granting shareholders more rights.

There is work from Armour, Siems et al that shows increasing shareholder power in some cases decreases prosperity as it significantly relates to reduced public listings.

We must also consider some of the seminal work on agency theory by the likes of Fama, who highlighted matters such as portfolio theory. Shareholders diversify their risk and have little incentive to monitor one company. There is also the problem of information asymmetries between company and shareholder, that even if they did have the incentive they may not be properly informed to make good or fully informed decisions.

There is also the fact the government point to other countries' practices, such as the US, France, and Australia, but ignore work by Tubner that highlights the impact of developing legal systems by analogy or legal transplant can result in legal irritants as laws operate out of context. Not to mention using Australia as an analogy for legal development of strengthening shareholder power ignores there own reforms of removing the 100-member rule that allows 100 shareholders to table resolutions at annual general meetings.

Then you have my own current work (forthcoming, so don't want to give too much away just yet) that shows even if shareholders tried to legally enforce anything against the company, the courts are parsimonious in allowing shareholders to enforce the company's rights due to restrictions on locus standi.

So, I am not sure the case is really made out, that the way to improve public confidence in business is to give shareholders more power. It is built on a faulty premise that: (1) we trust shareholders to make the right decision, or any decision at all; and (2) the faulty premise that the best way to achieve aggregate social welfare is to run companies for the shareholders' collective interest.

This begs the question, of course, what should we do? Now, I have many angles I could take on this, but I draw attention to Cheffins' work on whether law matters, and I also draw inspiration from Schynder's recent paper on why should law matter.

It would appear that the objective of reforming the law, i.e. why should law matter, is to improve public confidence. It does appear there are other objectives, such as deterrence, but confidence appears to be the main concern. The reasons for this are highlighted in the news article such as 'good governance helps companies take better decisions, for their own long-term benefit and the economy overall'; and 'businesses are a pillar of our society, creating employment opportunities and contributing significantly to funding our country's public services'. Seemingly if we are confident in what businesses are doing we can rely on them and we as the public and consumers become more confident in the market and continue to spend.

Cheffins points to the different ways investor confidence is improved, noting this is not achieved through increasing their rights. Factors such as financial intermediaries and the stock exchange are better at achieving this.  One must stress that this looked at increasing investor confidence, so one must be careful in drawing an analogy between investor and public confidence. But from this observation our working hypothesis could be increased shareholder rights will reduce public confidence in business.

It is taken from this that increasing shareholder rights we would observe a decrease in public confidence in business. While I said it was a danger to draw analogies with investor confidence as to whether increased rights would reduce public confidence, the hypothesis can be supported by the idea that shareholders, with their lack of incentives, will fail to monitor the company properly to increase confidence; those that do monitor the company will only do so to increase their own personal wealth; and when things do turn sour shareholders will lack the appropriate legal mechanisms to enforce the desired standards through the courts or company resolution.

If we want to increase public confidence we need more imaginative ways of doing that. Now, I am openly in favour of good regulation of business. I am not necessarily going to say what regulation that should be, as I do not think it is a matter for company law, nor is there the space or time to do so here. But, for example, employment law could be strengthened to support the statement above. That we rely on business for employment opportunities. We are not going to be confident in business if we feel they can remove us from our role in favour of short-sighted profit. So getting the balance of employment law right can help increase confidence. Yet, this Conservative government has gone about restricting employment rights.

This then boils down to what I said previously, these reforms are nothing more than palatable political responses.

Thursday, 20 March 2014

Eckerle & Ors v Wickeder Westfalenstahl GmbH [2013] EWHC 68

Introduction
The decision in Eckerle is of some significance to company law. It concerned the ability of a beneficiary in an investment chain being able to enforce rights within the company as a member within the definition of the Companies Act 2006, s. 112. The decision reached by Norris J caused him to remark that he had not reached 'a particularly comfortable conclusion, but reaching any other conclusion would involve an impermissible form of judicial legislation'. This has lead to debate about the role of investment intermediaries and their legal obligations with recent discussion on how if at all the law should be reformed to allow the ultimate beneficiary in an investment chain to exercise rights against issuers of securities.

Here I will give a brief summary of the case and discussion.

Facts and judgment
DNick Holding plc, registered in England but operated in Germany, was owned by Wickeder GmbH who acquired 75.005% of the company's shares (albeit through an intermediary, the significance of which is detailed below) giving it enough control to pass a special resolution (75%), which is required to make certain changes within the company.

The board of DNick proposed to cancel its shares and re-register as a private limited company (Ltd) for a public limited company (plc). This caused a drop in value of DNick's shares. A meeting was called and a special resolution was passed to re-register with Wickeder using its 75.005% ownership to secure it. The meeting was attended by shareholders (or their proxies) representing 83.71% of the vote.

Eckerle and Ors were claimed (claimed being the operative word) to be minority shareholders owning 6% of the issued shares. They commenced proceedings against Wickeder under section 98 of the Companies Act 2006 to have the resolution cancelled on the basis that they had standing to do so.

The Act under section 97 provides a company may re-register as a private company provided the conditions are met in this section and no application under section 98 has been made to cancel the resolution to re-register. Section 98 itself provides who may make such an application for cancellation and this includes: (a) the holders of not less in the aggregate than 5% in nominal value of the company's issued share capital; (b) ...; (c) ...; but (2) not by a person consented to or voted in favour of the resolution. Under subsection (3) the court may then make an order either cancelling or confirming the resolution.

Wickeder sought to strike this claim out, inter alia (see para [11]), on the basis there was no reasonable grounds on which the claim could be brought; or alternatively for summary judgment. The decision focused on the considerations set out for summary judgment and the dispute about the construction of the provisions in section 98 (see para [12]).

The key/common facts were laid out in para [14]. An important fact to note was that according to the share register DNick only had two registered shareholders who held the 5,671,318 issued ordinary shares. Dr Platt (CEO of Wickeder) held 1 share and the Bank of New York Depository (nominees) Ltd (BNY) the remainder. BNY acted as a depository of the issued shares, holding those shares on trust for account holders with Clearstream according to the account holder's respective holdings in Clearstream Interests (CI). Clearsteam was the settlement division of Desutsche Borse. Through Desutsche Borse trades on the relevant exchange between Clearstream account holders are transacted electronically. These account holders could not be individuals and could only be banks or financial institutions. What was traded on Desutsche Borse was the underlying ownership rights in DNick shares the CIs but not shares in DNick themselves. The trades were between Clearstream account holders, concluded on behalf of the customers of those account holders, who could be described as the end investor or ultimate beneficiary. Thus Eckerle and Ors plead to have 7.2% in the nominal value of the issued share capital but, in truth, they only have the ultimate economic interest in those securities which amounts to a specified percentage of the shares held by BNY on trust for Clearstream account holders whose customers Eckerle and Ors are.

As you can see, the claimants were far removed from the being the owners of the shares and simply held the economic interest in those securities. BNY held the shares, who held them on trust for Clearstream account holders whose customers the claimants are. They were 3 times removed in summary. This means when dividends are paid they are paid to BNY. Although the Articles did allow direct payment to Clearstream account holders who would ultimately account to its customers.

According to the facts set out at para [14] the company's articles provided that 'each person who is a CI holder at the relevant CI record date' can either direct the registered holder of the share how to exercise the vote attaching to the underlying share or to appoint a proxy to do so (who might be the end investor).

Thus it became important to identify who was the CI holder as it would give them the right to direct a vote or appoint a proxy. A CI holder was interpreted, according to the Articles, to mean 'the holder of [an interest in the shares in the capital of the company traded and settled through Clearsteam]'. They are then identified by the electronic register of CI holders. The only interests traded and settled through Clearstream are the interests of Clearstram account holders which were the banks and/or financial institutions. Only they fitted this description and so the right to appoint or direct would fall to them, not the account holders' customers. The Articles under Article 10 continued that DNick did not recognise beneficial interests and made clear they would not recognise any right except an absolute right to the 'entirety thereof in the registered holder'.

All of this ultimately lead to an initial observation that there is potentially a 'serious loophole in the protection afforded to minority shareholders'.

It was submitted for the claimants that, essentially section 98 should be interpreted widely and construe the provision as to who were holders as those who were shareholders in all but name and not simply those registered as holding the shares. At para [15] it was argued that: (1) section 98 should be construed with regard to the deliberate use of the terms 'holder' and 'person' instead of member; (2) alternatively the provision in section 145 should be approach purposively to enable the claimants to exercise rights otherwise vested in a member to enable that person to protect the economic value of their shares; (3) alternatively the common treatment of the holder of the ultimate economic interest as if he were a shareholder should mean in the present case that the prospects of the claimants showing that they were entitled to the relief they claimed cannot be dismissed as fanciful (required to allow the claim to proceed under the Civil Procedure Rules)

The first point was addressed that member or shareholder is one and only one (para [18]) citing at para [17] National Westminster Bank plc v Inland Revenue Commissioners [1995] 1 A.C. 119, 126. Therefore the claim that the term 'holder' should be interpreted widely was seen as needing an extremely strong reason to do so so as to depart from the orthodox understanding. Norris J continued at para [19] that the whole basis of the 2006 Act proceeds on the this basis as to the definition of a member, which is found in section 112 and concluded that the person who is registered as a member is rightfully deemed the holder of said shares. Thus, the definition does not include the person holding the ultimate economic interest. Norris J, at para [20] did not believe the specific use of the term 'holder' in section 98 should mean the court should look to the holder of the economic interest on the basis the other two subsections in section 98 referred to 'member'. He continued that under section 98 the court can only adjourn to have the shares purchased from the dissenting members. Therefore no relief could be granted to the holder of the ultimate economic interest.

Norris J continued in his reasoning that section 260 makes provisions in respect of rights directly enforceable by non-members, under section 260(5)(c) which states a member includes a person who is not a member but has been transferred shares in the company or has had them transmitted by operation of law. It was stated in Enviroco Ltd v Farstad Supply [2011] UKSC 16 at [37]-[38] that the term member is defined by section 112 and is a fundamental principle of company law and can only be departed from where expression provision allows it. Without such a principle company law would be unworkable.

Therefore section 98 does not apply to anyone expect those who are on the register.

However, Norris J continued to express reasons why summary judgment would not be given in favour of the claimants. He cites the Explanatory Notes for the 2006 Act at paragraph 210 and notes nobody believes on a true construction that section 98 extends to anybody beyond those members on the register.

Norris J further adds that the provisions in the Articles did not protect the claimants. These only provided that account holders i.e. Clearstream account holders (the banks or financial institutions) could direct BNY on how to vote or require BNY to appoint the account holder as proxy. Therefore the account holders could direct BNY as a member how to exercise its votes. As a result no rights are conferred upon the customers of the account holders under the articles.

To continue Norris J cites section 145 that provides anything required or authorised to be done by or in relation to the member shall be done or may instead be done by or in relation to the nominated person... as if he were a member of the company. This generally allows the nominated person to act is if they were a member of the company. However, section 145(4) adds that the section, nor does the Articles, 'confer rights enforceable against the company by anyone other than the member'. Norris J states at para [26] that these provisions were introduced due to investors increasingly holding their shares through intermediaries. Norris J elaborates at para [26], citing Hannigan, that company law 'demands a mechanism whereby the indirect investor can engage with, and be recognised, by the company'. But Hannigan admits such a mechanism, whilst ideal, would, in practice, be difficult. Hannigan, as cited by Norris J, states section 145 is a modest step forward in achieving this but is not a radical departure from recognising the member as the one who is registered as such.

Therefore section 145(4) does not confer enforceable rights on anyone expect for the registered shareholders, which in this case is Dr Platt and BNY. Therefore failure to recognise the nominated person or afford them the same treatment as if they were a member, does not give enforceable rights to that nominated person. The only person who can enforce is the registered shareholder. At para [27] Norris J, citing Buckley, gave the example of failing to notify a nominated individual of a meeting. Whilst the company has to recognise that nomination and inform them accordingly, failure to do so would only allow the registered shareholder to challenge that failure.

Norris J concluded that from the submissions presented none lead to the conclusion that the account holders, let alone the claimants could enforce section 98. He states at para [29] 'These passages simply mean that the statutory rights that are directly exercisable by the nominated person are those which enable the right conferred and transfered by the articles to be effectively transferred'. He notes that this is why section 145(2) operates 'so far as is necessary to give effect [to the provision in the company's articles enabling a member to nominate another person as entitled to enjoy or exercise ... any specified rights of the member in relation to the company]'. Norris J stated that this 'does not mean that if the effective exercise of the transferred right produces a result that is not to the taste of the nominated person then the nominated person can, in order to bring about his desired outcome, himself use any of the provisions of the 2006 Act available to the transferring member'. As a result Norris J concluded the claimants were neither holders within a true construction of section 98, nor did section 145 enable them to bring a claim. Norris J also noted that there was no expectation beyond what the Articles said that would allow the ultimate beneficiaries to enforce said rights on the basis of the well known dicta in Re Astec (BSR) plc [1999] BCC 59, 87 that made clear that such expectations have no place in public listed companies and the public dealing in the market proceed on the basis of what is in the Articles.

Finally, Norris J suggested that it could add BNY as a party to the proceedings but deemed this would not be capable as BNY was a person who had voted in favour of the resolution to re-register the company as private and could not make an application under section 98 which bars those who voted in favour from doing so. This, in itself, was seen as problematic at para [32]. If the holder of the legal interest in the share has been instructed to vote in favour of the resolution it will make them incapable of  commencing proceedings for any ultimate beneficiary dissenting from the resolution.

All of this lead to Norris' J uncomfortable conclusion that the ultimate beneficiary would be deprived of protection, which those who formulated the 2006 Act thought should be extended to.

Summary
In summary, the claimants were not members. They could not apply under section 98 to have the re-registration cancelled, nor could they apply under section 145 to enforce rights as nominees because they were not nominees and by any means this section does not confer enforcement rights on nominees, those are vested in the shareholders only. As well BNY could not commence proceedings on behalf of the ultimate beneficiaries as it had barred itself from doing so by voting in favour of the resolution.

Discussion
It seems quite right to postulate that investment has become so complex that investors are prevented from exercising their rights against the issuer. It is agreed that giving a mechanism to allow the end investor to enforce rights is likely to be impractical, as Hannigan argued, potentially opening up the floodgates to claims including duplicate claims, as well as the increased cost and time in maintaing a accurate share register. However, moving away from the orthodox concept of 'member' may not be catastrophic if approached with the right caution. The 2006 Act itself moved away from another fundamental principle of company law, namely majority rule, with the introduction of the statutory derivative claim, allowing any member to enforce a right vested in the company in respect of a breach of duty, trust, default or negligence. This removed the bar of wrongdoer control and the rule in Foss v Harbottle (1847) 67 ER 189, which only allowed a derivative claim to proceed in the common law where it was shown  the wrongdoers were in control of the company, because where they were not it was for the majority to decide if the company should litigate and not an individual shareholder. This was overcome by putting relevant restrictions in place on allowing a claim, such as mandatory bars where the conduct has been ratified or authorised by an unconnected majority. Further the court is given the discretion to consider whether the conduct is likely to be ratified or authorised as well as taking in to consideration the views of disinterested shareholders. Cases brought under the new statutory claim have also been dismissed at the court's discretion where wrongdoers were not in control, so whilst it is not a bar to a claim, the court may use its discretion when determining whether to allow a claim and consider the issue of wrongdoer control. Therefore, it is tentatively suggested that it may be appropriate to open up derivative claims to end investors, extending section 260(5) or introduce a similar concept that allows end investors to litigate pending court approval. This may eliminate the objection raised by Hannigan about cost and the issue of the floodgates being opened by imposing appropriate safeguards on standing. As well, the law reformers may draw on many areas for inspiration where protection for end users has been developed, which was seemingly difficult if not impossible before intervention such as the Consumer Protection Act 1987, part 1 which protected consumers from defective products put in to the market by manufacturers.

Another concern is the intermediary who acts for multiple beneficiaries. In this case it may have been in the interest of some of its end investors to vote in favour of the resolution but not for others. However, initially it seems, BNY would not have acted against their duties in doing so. They have acted in the interests of the end investors by voting the way they believed to be the best interests of the end investor or were subsequently instructed to do so by Clearstream account holders who equally would have instructed based on what they believed to be the best interests of the end investors. Being barred from applying to the courts was a result of the statute and not mala fides.

Whether there is a fiduciary breach would require deeper analysis. Yes, the position can rightly be described as fiduciary but it is not clear if the duty of loyalty would have been breached. This requires a conflict of interest, which itself requires the fiduciary (i.e. the investment intermediary, in this case BNY and Clearstream account holders) to suspend self-interest and the interest of others and act in the sole interests of the beneficiary. By acting for multiple beneficiaries it is possible a conflict has arisen between the interests of the respected beneficiaries and if that is so the only way the intermediary may immunise themselves from liability is to get authorisation to act or alternatively demonstrate that there was not a conflict. The latter would require the fiduciary to demonstrate that they had not taken responsibility for the particular interest of the beneficiary allowing them to act against it for others. See, for example, Kelly v Cooper [1993] A.C. 205. The question then is whether by acting for multiple beneficiaries and voting on the same resolution, is this a conflict of interest? My answer would be yes. There is a risk that by acting for more than one beneficiary that their loyalty to one may compromise their loyalty to the other, similar to that seen in Extrasure Travel Insurance v Scattergood [2003] 1 BCLC 598. However, a further problem here is that even if it is a breach, the end investor may still be left without a remedy since in duty-duty conflicts the fiduciary may not profit personally. Therefore there is no profit to disgorge to the end investor. They would then have to try and claim equitable compensation but this requires causation i.e. a link between the actions of the fiduciary and the loss suffered. This may be difficult to show that the way they voted caused the loss suffered since one investor (Wickeder) "owned" 75.005% thus the loss would seemingly have been suffered regardless but I think this needs more analysis to be certain on how difficult it would be to prove than this blog post will offer.

As well, claiming this is a breach of fiduciary duty may cause practical problems for investment intermediaries as it would seemingly impact on their ability to act for clients without authorisation, which in turn may increase the cost of engaging with an investment intermediary.











Thursday, 21 June 2012

Directors' pay: Guide to government reforms: It is not transparency it is simplification

I am thinking these reforms are as watered down as I was on my way to work this morning. The government has published its report on directors' pay reform proposals.

These plans are to strengthen the hand of shareholders and increase transparency. Well I think transparency is the wrong word because that implies more disclosure. Well in fact most of what is being proposed is already disclosed in most if not all annual reports. What these proposals are, is at best simplification.

I do not think I have to discuss the proposal to give shareholders a binding vote to a great extent. This is simply a bad idea. The government has pandered to its audience that believe shareholders own the company and somehow employee the directors. Quite simply they don't. The company as a separate legal personality appoints directors to undertake responsibility for its assets. It is for the company to reward its directors, not the shareholders. But for this to remain viable and for there to be a reduction in agency costs there needs to be a body of independent directors who reward the executive directors who actively run the company. This is where the real problem has stemmed from. These independent directors only became prominent on boards when they became useful to the executives, i.e. through helping in strategy and advice. Supposed independent non-executives have become increasingly involved with the running and strategy of the company which reduces their independence.

Thus I remain unconvinced that shareholders deserve a stronger hand. They buy shares in a company, they do not own it. If they do not like what the bought then they can sell it.

If remuneration is going to be managed properly you need to ensure that the non-executives who are deciding on remuneration are truly independent. This does not mean all non-executives need to take a step back, just those deciding remuneration. The Corporate Governance Code or the Financial Reporting Council is suggesting to revise the Code with measures on restrictions in regard to executives sitting on remuneration committees at other companies. This is probably a positive step, but one from the FRC rather than the government proposals. See here for relevant links.

For some of the proposals...

It would be interesting to see how the government tries to disclose details of the directors' employment contracts. Their rights as an employee are separate for rights as a director. I am not quite sure if this is something that should be published in annual reports. More information needed though before further comment.

The proposals want details of what directors will get paid for performance that is above, below or on target. Well anyone who owns a calculator could figure that out from the annual report already. They are required to disclose the shares awarded in a particular year and share price they were awarded at. They also publish the criteria that performance is measured against at the percentage that will vest depending on what targets they meet. Some firms do in fact already publish an estimated value at maximum vesting of the awards.

Thus this point does highlight that it is simplification and not increased transparency.

They also want information on the change of profit, dividends and the overall spend on pay. Well yet again this information is available through the annual reports. It is just more simplification.

They also want material facts taken in to consideration when setting pay to be published. Well let us face it, that is not worth the paper it is written on. Not to mention in most cases companies do already publish this. BP for example after the oil spill detailed their consideration of that matter in awarding remuneration. It did not stop their chief executive resigning that year on a package worth well over £5million if I remember correctly. What is the Government expecting from this proposal. A declaration that they considered these wider interests and then ignored them anyway. Increased evidence of watered-down simplification.

Table B of the proposals in the report do not seem to have any differences from what is already required of companies in annual reports. The requirement of a total single figure of remuneration does require companies to publish a single figure that includes variable pay and pensions. Again, the trusty calculator could have already done this without the need for reform. Apparently this figure will be calculated using a methodology complied by the FRC to include actual pay earned rather than potential pay awarded. However, the report does not clarify how this will then encompass pensions since this is never pay earned and is merely a debt on the company's balance sheet.

These are early days though. The next steps are for the government to bring forward reforms to the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Bill as well as publishing revised Regulations setting out what companies must publish on directors' pay.

Friday, 11 May 2012

If you haven't got anything nice to say... don't say anything: The Company Remuneration Bill

Ok so the title of this post is a bit of a misnomer. I do have one good thing to say. Good thing to say about what? Well I am referring to the Company Remuneration Bill that received its first reading in the House of Lords today. The triumphant Bill consists all of four sections. This Bill is, however, unlikely to become law, see here, but below I shall highlight some problems that may be informative for any regulation the government does eventually introduce.

So let's deal with each section in turn (excluding section 4 which is merely stating its application):

Section 1(1): Decisions of remuneration committees as to the remuneration of the directors and five highest paid employees, before implementation, must be ratified by an ordinary resolution.

Comment:
I have repeatedly pointed out apathy amongst shareholders. Ok yes there has been a bit of a rebellion as of late. But if we are truly honest most of that hype has come from the media. How long will this "shareholder activism" actually last? Not long.

I have also banged on about better non-executives on remuneration committees yet there is no mention of non-executives anywhere in the Bill. Surely the pay packages that were awarded to the directors at Aviva show a complete disregard for common sense amongst non-executives. If non-executives did their job properly there would have been no need for this tighter regulation.

With that in mind there does need to be some mechanism to prevent excess beyond non-executives. As the crisis highlighted, remuneration continually rose as it was a way of attracting the best talent with no consideration of the actual amount. Thus the formation of an independent regulator whom shareholders could complain to would be more desirable surely than trying to coordinate large groups of shareholders in public companies?

Section 1(2): Such decisions MUST be voted on in a secret ballot by all the company's employees, although this is not legally binding

Comment:
Yes this is a section. You have a remuneration committee, shareholders, and now employees second guessing what you are going to get paid. So much uncertainty and so many voices. Why do the creditors not get a vote if you give one to employees? The non-executives are there to be independent and award remuneration. If they do not do their job correctly they should be fired. The term overkill is certainly coming to mind with executive remuneration.

The wording is very interesting. The words "must" and "all" seem a bit optimistic. Are all the employees really going to vote? Did all public sector workers vote whether to strike?

Section 2(1): Where a ballot is held under section 1(2) this must be reported in the following year's annual report

Comment:
Well this section slightly ignores the wording of the one prior. If the decisions must be voted on by all the company's employees then ipso facto it will need to be published under section 2(1). Surely all that needs to be said under section 2(1) is the results of the ballot must be published if one is always required to be made.

Section 2(2): The remuneration report must prominently feature the remuneration ratio between the highest paid director or employee and average remuneration of the lowest remunerated 10% of employees.

Comment:
So this is something I actually agree on. In fact I do not think it goes far enough. I feel that long term incentive plans should probably have employee remuneration criteria attached to it. As such executive remuneration should not go up when employees are made redundant. At least some publication of the ratio will put things in to perspective for directors by physically having to consider the differences.

In fact this may be great for executives if they decide to fire everyone in the lowest 10% since the ratio will decrease... certainly food for thought as to the wording and ratio to be disclosed...

Section 3: Interpretation

Comment:
OK so I wish to focus on the interpretation of one particular word. That is "remuneration". This section defines remuneration as "all rewards and benefits, including, inparticular, share options, bonuses, beneficial rights and salaries.

Well for anyone who knows even the slightest bit about remuneration this section is as confusing as it can possibly get. In the UK remuneration already has two meanings where there are already discrepancies. So this is in fact a third definition that clearly has no consideration as to the differences between the different types of compensation paid to directors. I have discussed these different definitions and award schemes elsewhere, see here.

The definition says all rewards and benefits. Well surely that includes long term incentive plans? But how do you accurately quantify long term incentive plans? A director is not given the shares in long term incentive plans upon award. He has to satisfy criteria over a three year period. If that criteria is not satisfied then the shares do not vest and the director gets nothing. So do we assess the remuneration for Long Term Plans at all when working out the ratio between highest and lowest paid in accordance with section 2(2)? Do you calculate long term plans on the value at the time of the award by multiplying share price by shares awarded; or simply go on the value of the shares that actually vest?

Long Term Plans are also not the only problem. Are pensions to be included? Pensions again are not monies paid by the company. They are merely a debt on the company's books.

Share options also suffer from the same problem as Long Term Incentive Plans. A director only gets rewarded if he exercises those options. So at what point do you assess their value?

Finally as I mentioned, how does this definition of remuneration interplay with the other two found in the Listing Rules and the 2008 Regulations? Surely three definitions of remuneration is more complicated than one. If the idea was to simplify remuneration, I would not call this a good start. The problem with trying to simplify is that it will probably make it more confusing if you attempt to generalise remuneration. Although the rules may seem complex to an outsider, to someone with knowledge of the area the purposes behind the rigid definitions and different mechanisms become clear and quite simple to understand.

My final thought is this goes to show something so true in company law. If you do not regulate yourselves properly, the government will impose something worse.